Maitland Quitmeyer, an editor here at BuzzFeed, owns multiple pairs of these and wears them like, all. the. time. Here are some excerpts from her longer Target Michaela Pumps review (#4): "They have a shortish (2.5") stacked heel, which honestly makes them feel like flats. I can wear them with midi dresses, jeans, and shorts and mini dresses without feeling like they're too tall. I've walked miiiles in them, and the straps at the ankle and front of the foot are actually comfy! You know when sandals have that really scratchy stitching that just attacks your feet? These do NOT have that. And the arch is pleasantly contoured, actually supporting my feet as I pound the pavement."
And oh yes, the reviewers on Target's site are in love with them, too.
Promising review: "These are the most comfortable heels I’ve ever worn and I don’t even like wearing heels. I wore them to my graduation ceremony and was able to stand in them and walk for a good while and go to a bar and drink with friends after. I was in the heels for six hours walking down the street, to the bar, standing and dancing before they started to be painful." —Meka
Get them from Target for $24.99 (available in five colors — the fifth, taupe, is $24.99 here — and sizes 5–12, including wide styles, although because it's the end of the season some sizes in some colors are out of stock).